Sunday, March 12, 2006

New Jersey For Change

Dear reader[s],

Let me introduce you to a relatively new blog, New Jersey For Change. Started only three weeks ago by Chanice, with help from her nameless cousin, NJFC has already covered a local teacher gone big time, the Corzine bail scandal, state government spending, school performance, and corruption. She's even been attacked by the left side of the state blogosphere in her comments, where DBK called her a "[phallic epithet]", "complete schmuck," "full of [fecal matter]," "ignorant," "lying, dishonest little [phallic epithet]," "lying [fecal matter]," "low-life," and "lying [alternative phallic epithet]," all in the span of two hours. I'd say Chanice is off to a good start. Stop by New Jersey for Change and see for yourself.

Tags: New Jersey Bloggers, Spending, Corruption, Taxes, Corzine

Saturday, March 11, 2006

The Governor's Budget Presentation

In a piece titled One Dimensional Thinking, Paul Nelson of NJ Fiscal Folly critiques the governor's recent budget presentation. He concentrates on the weakly stated debt problem, which is huge, but I'd like to point out another hidden feature of the presentation.
The governor claims, on slide 3, that "Deterioration began in the late 1980’s and continued Deterioration began in the late 1980’s and continued under both Democratic and Republican under both Democratic and Republican administrations," but the data don't really support that claim. Look at the slowing growth in appropriations on slide 5, where from FY 1997 through 2004 the annual rate of increase averaged about 7.5% per year. The most significant problem was the McGreevey budget of 2005, which increased appropriations by more than 16%, using an unprecedented number of gimmicks and shams to pretend that it was balanced.
Acting Governor Codey's 2006 budget, in contrast, appropriated about 3% less than 2005. He recognized that spending restraint was required to get the state's financial house in order.
Corzine wants to return to the McGreevey policy of ridiculous growth in spending. As shown in slide 12, projected growth this year is $4.9 Billion, or more than 18%, with the largest chunk dedicated to "State, College, and Teacher Employee Pension & Health Benefits."
This kind of profligate spending cannot stand. Revenues are projected to grow at 3-4% each year without any changes to the current tax structure. State expenditures growth should be limited to what we can afford, and if hard choices must be made, so be it. I have not taken a vacation or bought a new car since moving to New Jersey in 2001 because my personal revenue growth did not allow for such additional expenditures. Shouldn't I expect the same behavior of my government?

Tags: Spending, Taxes, Corzine

Thursday, March 02, 2006

State Business Tax Climate Index

Enlighten-New Jersey, Dynamobuzz, and NJ Fiscal Folly have all hit on The Tax Foundation's State Business Tax Climate Index. New Jersey, in case you didn't already know it, is just about the worst possible place to locate a business when considering tax issues.

I was curious what the overall impact of this tax climate was on the state's economy, so I went and dug up the latest Gross State Product (GSP) report from the federal Bureau of Economic Analysis. The numbers are pretty staggering, especially when you look at the top and bottom 10 states identified by the Tax Foundation:

The ten best states in the Tax Foundation’s 2006 State Business Tax Climate Index are as follows:

1. Wyoming
2. South Dakota
3. Alaska
4. Florida
5. Nevada
6. New Hampshire
7. Texas
8. Delaware
9. Montana
10. Oregon

The ten worst states in the SBTCI are as follows:

41. Arkansas
42. Iowa
43. Nebraska
44. Kentucky
45. Maine
46. Vermont
47. Ohio
48. Rhode Island
49. New Jersey
50. New York
In the latest year for which state-level data were available (2003-2004), the overall US growth rate was 4.3 percent. The top 10 states in the rankings above hit an average for 4.67 5.2 percent, while the bottom 10 states averaged 3.44 percent[1] . This supports the point made by the Tax Foundation, and also highlighted by Enlighten - Taxes Matter. States with favorable tax climates outperformed the overall US economy, while those with unfavorable taxes underperformed. The 10 best states accounted for 16.6% of the total US economy, and delivered 19.9% of the growth. Meanwhile the bottom 10 states made up 19.8% of the economy but only created 18.5% of the growth. New Jersey's GSP is 3.6% of GDP, but our growth was only 2.8% of the national total.
It doesn't get much simpler than this. Make your tax system fair, and your state will prosper. Complicate your tax system, failing to treat taxpayers equally and you will lag behind.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes

________________
[1] As I put together this rebuttal to Xpatriated Texan's post on this subject, I realized that I had made a calculation error. The top 10 states did not average 4.67% growth as I had noted. As you can see from the table in the rebuttal, the average growth was actually 5.2%. I can't account for the error (didn't save my working Excel™ file), and I stand corrected on this point. This correction will also be appended to the original.

Monday, February 27, 2006

Lighter than usual blogging this week

Yeah, I know. Both of you are saying to yourselves, how could he possibly blog less?

Simple. I'm traveling for work. We have customers who need to be contacted, and it must be done in person. It's a tough, dirty job, but someone's got to do it.

in Hawaii! I'm sitting in my Waikiki hotel room with the sliding glass doors open and the cool evening breeze blowing the scent of flowers into my room.

Have fun in sunny Jersey, kids!

Tags: Travel, Not in Jersey

Saturday, February 25, 2006

State Tax Collections

Paul Nelson of NJ Fiscal Folly pointed out a very interesting site to me today. The state legislature's Office of Legislative Services puts out a periodic Revenue Snapshot to document collections and compare them to the budget. In the latest report (from December), we see that

With December revenue collections again outpacing expected growth rates, it appears likely that revenue estimates for Fiscal Year 2006 will be revised upward later this Spring. The magnitude of the upward revision will depend upon important revenue collections in January and April. Eleven of the 14 major State revenues that
the OLS tracks each month are reporting growth rates above what would be needed to reach year end certified targets. Of the State's largest revenues, only the sales tax is under performing expectations at this time.

A little bit more detailed look at the numbers shows that the state has collected nearly $530 million more than it had budgeted through the first six months of the year - $61 for each and every one of the 8.7 million people in our state.
This money does not "belong" to the state. The government should not treat this as found money, and plan to spend it. Unfortunately, it looks like that's exactly what they will do.


Tags: Jersey, Taxes

What Pizza Topping are You?

This post is dedicated to Jim, who can't think of anything to blog about today.

Sausage
You scored -27 flavor!
Sometimes I like you; sometimes I don't.



My test tracked 1 variable How you compared to other people your age and gender:
free online datingfree online dating
You scored higher than 25% on flavor
Link: The What Pizza Topping Am I? Test


Tags: Quizzes, Pizza

Saturday, February 18, 2006

NJ SCC Annual Report III

Every time I look at the NJ Schools Construction Corporation annual report, I get more and more perturbed. Here's another interesting fact I extracted from the data, showing what a serious problem we have.
The average school construction project for the 2004-05 school year took 17.9 months, which sounds pretty reasonable. Break them down by what organizations managed them, however, and the difference is startling. The 355 projects managed by the districts averaged 17.1 months to complete, while the 24 projects completed by SCC took an average of 29.4 months. That's more than a year longer than the locally managed jobs. The table below lays out the average project length (in months) by completion date.

Year Month Districts SCC Grand Total
2004 Jul 13.1 29.3 13.7

Aug 16.2 28.5 17.3

Sep 19.2 26.1 20.9

Oct 21.8
21.8

Nov 17.0 28.6 18.8

Dec 18.9 29.5 19.6
2005 Jan 11.5 31.4 12.0

Feb 17.9 30.1 18.5

Mar 16.3
16.3

Apr 18.9 33.1 19.3

May 17.9 42.8 18.5

Jun 19.3 31.7 21.5
Grand Total
17.1 29.4 17.9

So, not only is NJ SCC incapable of estimating or controlling costs, but it apparently is also incapable of completing its jobs in a reasonable amount of time.

The SCC must be closed. The people of New Jersey have poured far too much money into this sink hole.

Tags: Jersey, Taxes, Education, NJSCC

NJ SCC Annual Report II

In a comment to my first post on this subject, Joe says:

Just think most of the work done on the schools is by non union contractors. I'll bet if they were done by union contractors they would be done faster and cheaper.
Either Joe has an extremely dry wit, or he is simply uninformed. You see, New Jersey practically requires the use of union labor on school construction projects funded by the SCC. This is done through a mandate for Project Labor Agreements (PLAs). According to he SCC web site:
On January 18, 2002 Governor McGreevey signed Executive Order 1, which provides that:

On a project-by-project basis, a state department, authority, or instrumentality shall include a PLA in a public works project where it has been determined that the agreement advances the state's interests of cost efficiency, quality, safety, timeliness, skilled labor force, labor stability, and the state's policy to advance minority and women-owned businesses.

On July 30, 2002 Governor McGreevey signed legislation that authorizes the use of Project Labor Agreements on major public works projects.
These PLAs do nothing but add costs to a project. For example, they require each contractor and sub-contractor to have a registered apprentice program, driving up the contractor's labor cost by making him hire untrained people. PLAs also specify whom the contractor must hire:
A PLA must require the contractor to provide "whatever resources necessary" to prepare for the apprenticeship of the number of women and minorities as set forth in the publicly available plan.
On top of the PLA requirement, New Jersey also requires that contractors pay the "prevailing wage" to their employees on public projects. The prevailing wage is typically set at whatever rate the unions demand (emphasis added):
The Act requires the payment of minimum rates of pay to laborers, craftsmen and apprentices employed on public works projects. Covered workers must receive the appropriate craft prevailing wage rate as determined by the Commissioner of Labor and Workforce Development. Prevailing wage rates are wage rates based on the collective bargaining agreements established for a particular craft or trade
If they fail to do so, then they are debarred from bidding on any public project in the state. The current list of debarred firms runs 20 pages.

Just how expensive is this? Let's look at a single job - new construction painting. Imagine a job where you need four painters for two and a half (8-hr) days to knock out the work, or a total of 80 hours of actual work. According to the Burlington County prevailing wage rates (pages 40-41), a Journeyman painter must be paid $45.30 an hour (including $13.25 in benefits). The contractor must also pay social security taxes of 6.2% on the labor rate, driving his total cost to $47.29 per hour, or $3,782 for the job.
But that's not all. The state requires all contractors to have apprentice programs as noted above, and in the prevailing wage determination (page 68) sets the ratio of apprentices required. For painters, it's 1:4, so on this job we have to add an apprentice. His rate is also set in the same document (page 65), and for a mid-level apprentice (1.5 years) its 70% of the journeyman's wage, or $31.71, plus $6.27 in benefits, plus $1.97 for social security - $39.95 per hour, or $799 for the 20-hour duration of the job. The apprenticeship requirement is, in effect, a 21% increase in project cost.

What would this project cost if the prevailing wage and PLA requirements were not in place? The lowest possible cost would be the minimum wage, currently $6.15 per hour, plus the 6.2% social security tax. That would set the labor cost at $522. Now, on a new construction project, I don't want a crappy job, so I would want to hire someone with some skill and experience. If I was willing to pay three times the minimum wage for this work, it would cost $1,567 to get the job done. I don't know if those are reasonable rates, so I checked craigslist in the Philly area and found an independent "Professional painter/paperhanger looking to stay busy." He claims thirty years experience, has his own equipment, is fully insured and is willing to work as a subcontractor. His rate: $25/hr. If I hire him as a sub (letting him pay his own social security out of his quoted rate) to do my hypothetical job, this painter would cost me about $2,000.

Non-union subcontractor at $2,000, or meet the PLA and prevailing wage requirements for $4,581. Which is more cost effective, Joe?

Tags: Jersey, Taxes, Education, NJSCC

Friday, February 17, 2006

NJ Schools Construction Corporation Annual Report

[Welcome, Carnival riders! If you find this post enlightening, there's more here and here].

The New Jersey Schools Construction Corporation has published its annual report to the governor and legislature. Paul Nelson of NJ Fiscal Folly provides a nice, simple summary of the document: We're All Doomed, Doomed I Tell You!

Painfully, I've read the whole thing. It's not pretty, but the $12.8 billion cost widely quoted in the press is nothing more than a fantasy. The details of this fantasy start on page 77 of the report, but here's the game they are playing:
Step 1: Take the January 2005 construction cost estimates (CCEs) from the project management firms (PMFs) and add 7.5% escalation for the age of the estimates
Step 2: Add a further 15% "contingency"
Step 3: Add 2% to the design fees to account for restarting the work that was stopped
Step 4: Add 1-1.5% for permit fees, plus 0.25% for "other miscellaneous fees"
Step 5: Add 0.5% for temporary space.
Step 6: Add 2% for Schools Construction Corporation overhead.
Here's a real killer: "PMFs are compensated based on a percentage of the CCE of projects that they are managing." In other words, the PMFs are incentivized to generate construction cost estimates that are as high as possible.
So, in summary, an artificially inflated construction cost estimate is then further inflated by nearly 30%.
After establishing a nice, high baseline, SCC then moves to scare us into buying in now rather than later. They take the baseline, and further inflate it for two ridiculous cases -- waiting five or ten years to start the same projects. They apply an annual 7.5% inflator to the construction costs, and 15% inflation to the land acquisition costs. From page 81:

The proposed 15% adjustment is largely due to the anticipated increased value of real estate (primarily residential) and also takes into account anticipated increased cost for services (outside legal counsel, appraisal, review appraisal, title, relocation and property maintenance). The adjustment for anticipated market conditions is based on the SCC’s experience in all Abbott District market areas except Phillipsburg, Vineland and Millville over the past 5 years. All market segments, as seen in the Market Studies (Residential, Industrial and Commercial), have advanced significantly (largely 15 - 20%) each year since 2001. These studies are based on unaltered sales data from the Multiple Listing Service.
Apparently, they haven't been reading Grim over at the Northern New Jersey Real Estate Bubble. There's always the possibility that Grim is wrong, but no market can go up forever. Take a look at the Camden area, for example, since Camden is an Abbott District. Recently, the market's been climbing at a pretty good clip, based on the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight's quarterly home price index (last updated for 3rd quarter 2005).

Note: In each of the following charts, the blue line represents the home price index (left scale), while the red line indicates rate of change (right scale). I know the clarity isn't very good, but I will try to clean it up later.



There was a similar growth trend in the Camden market back in the 80s, as you can see here:


But what happened in between? Nothing! The market was essentially flat for about six years, as you can see in the next chart.

My point here is simple: previous year market trends cannot be used to reliably predict future movement! The Schools Construction Corporation wants us to believe that it can accurately estimate the cost of a construction project five-to-ten years from now, when it cannot even get a handle on current year spending. I think we ought to give them five-to-ten years, but in a Federal prison rather than in our wallets.

Governor Corzine, do not spend another dime of my money on this fiasco. Cut our losses, ignore the arrogant Supreme Court, and stop feeding cash into the gaping maw of the Abbott Districts.

Tags: Jersey, Taxes, Education, NJSCC

Wednesday, February 15, 2006

54th midway of the Carnival of Education

The Carnival of Education is up over at The EdWahoo. They were kind enough to pick up my post on recent hish school proficiency scores in New Jersey. Lots and lots of links to peruse, covering the gamut of educational issues.

Carnival of the GOP Bloggers 1

A new Carnival comes to town: the Carnival of the GOP Bloggers. Check it out - simple, short, and very interesting.

Tuesday, February 14, 2006

Sci-Fi Profile

Thanks to Sluggo, I took the Sci-Fi Profile quiz. Then answer was both surprising and cool:

You scored as SG-1 (Stargate). You are versatile and diverse in your thinking. You have an open mind to that which seems highly unlikely and accept it with a bit of humor. Now if only aliens would stop trying to take over your body.

SG-1 (Stargate)

100%

Serenity (Firefly)

94%

Moya (Farscape)

88%

Nebuchadnezzar (The Matrix)

88%

Babylon 5 (Babylon 5)

81%

Deep Space Nine (Star Trek)

69%

Enterprise D (Star Trek)

69%

Millennium Falcon (Star Wars)

69%

Galactica (Battlestar: Galactica)

69%

FBI's X-Files Division (The X-Files)

69%

Bebop (Cowboy Bebop)

63%

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda)

56%

Your Ultimate Sci-Fi Profile II: which sci-fi crew would you best fit in? (pics)
created with QuizFarm.com

Monday, February 13, 2006

Cheney Shoots Hunting Partner. Minorities and Children Most Affected

I'm sure everyone knows by now that Vice President Cheney accidentally peppered his hunting partner with birdshot yesterday. A terrible thing to happen, and I'm sure the VP feels horrible about it. Fortunately, it turned out to be "just a flesh wound."

Jack at Jersey Persepective poses the question, What If Cheney Had Killed Him?

... it makes you think, what if Cheney had killed the guy? Would it make headlines in papers (tabloids excluded)? Would Cheney resign? Which brings us to the next question. Who would a)be selected to take Cheney's place as VP[?]
I think it likely that, had this been a fatal accident, Cheney would have offered his resignation to the President. The real question is, would the President accept such an offer? Cheney at that point would still be a brilliant administrator, and a cunning politician, moving with great skill through the halls of power in Washington. In other words, a key asset to the administration. If I were the President, I would not allow Cheney to resign.

If the situation became such that Cheney was unable to perform his duties, then I would consider accepting it, and would look for a replacement in Cheney's mold. Someone with demonstrated political skill inside the beltway, strong on national security affairs, polished diplomatically, and [breaking the mold] appealing to the general public. The position requires someone who has effectively led, as the chief executive, large organizations, because I am really picking my own potential replacement. I could think of no one better suited to those qualifications than Dr. Condoleeza Rice.

Thanks, Jack, for the thought provoking questions. No thanks, however, for the sophomoric final question, "and b)who would run the Bush adminstration?"

Tags: Dick Cheney, Shotgun, Hunting, Accident, Politics

Sunday, February 12, 2006

Carnival of the New Jersey Bloggers 39

Bob at eCache hosts the latest Carnival of the New Jersey Bloggers, the 39th and apparently biggest edition yet! I overloaded my browser with tabs trying to open all of the interesting links. Go check it out.

Tags: Carnival of the New Jersey Bloggers