Tuesday, April 18, 2006

Thank God for our Forefathers

We often forget significant dates in our history as a nation, or the remembrance becomes clouded with modern changes. Yesterday, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts celebrated Patriots' Day, featuring the Boston Marathon and a Red Sox afternoon baseball game. I am aware of no other state that celebrated these events, but they must be remembered.
To help jog your memory, please read Longfellow's Paul Revere's Ride, and remember:

Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere,
On the eighteenth of April, in Seventy-five;
Hardly a man is now alive
Who remembers that famous day and year.

He said to his friend, "If the British march
By land or sea from the town to-night,
Hang a lantern aloft in the belfry arch
Of the North Church tower as a signal light,--
One if by land, and two if by sea;
And I on the opposite shore will be,
Ready to ride and spread the alarm
Through every Middlesex village and farm,
For the country folk to be up and to arm."

Then he said "Good-night!" and with muffled oar
Silently rowed to the Charlestown shore,
Just as the moon rose over the bay,
Where swinging wide at her moorings lay
The Somerset, British man-of-war;
A phantom ship, with each mast and spar
Across the moon like a prison bar,
And a huge black hulk, that was magnified
By its own reflection in the tide.

Meanwhile, his friend through alley and street
Wanders and watches, with eager ears,
Till in the silence around him he hears
The muster of men at the barrack door,
The sound of arms, and the tramp of feet,
And the measured tread of the grenadiers,
Marching down to their boats on the shore.

Then he climbed the tower of the Old North Church,
By the wooden stairs, with stealthy tread,
To the belfry chamber overhead,
And startled the pigeons from their perch
On the sombre rafters, that round him made
Masses and moving shapes of shade,--
By the trembling ladder, steep and tall,
To the highest window in the wall,
Where he paused to listen and look down
A moment on the roofs of the town
And the moonlight flowing over all.

Beneath, in the churchyard, lay the dead,
In their night encampment on the hill,
Wrapped in silence so deep and still
That he could hear, like a sentinel's tread,
The watchful night-wind, as it went
Creeping along from tent to tent,
And seeming to whisper, "All is well!"
A moment only he feels the spell
Of the place and the hour, and the secret dread
Of the lonely belfry and the dead;
For suddenly all his thoughts are bent
On a shadowy something far away,
Where the river widens to meet the bay,--
A line of black that bends and floats
On the rising tide like a bridge of boats.

Meanwhile, impatient to mount and ride,
Booted and spurred, with a heavy stride
On the opposite shore walked Paul Revere.
Now he patted his horse's side,
Now he gazed at the landscape far and near,
Then, impetuous, stamped the earth,
And turned and tightened his saddle girth;
But mostly he watched with eager search
The belfry tower of the Old North Church,
As it rose above the graves on the hill,
Lonely and spectral and sombre and still.
And lo! as he looks, on the belfry's height
A glimmer, and then a gleam of light!
He springs to the saddle, the bridle he turns,
But lingers and gazes, till full on his sight
A second lamp in the belfry burns.

A hurry of hoofs in a village street,
A shape in the moonlight, a bulk in the dark,
And beneath, from the pebbles, in passing, a spark
Struck out by a steed flying fearless and fleet;
That was all! And yet, through the gloom and the light,
The fate of a nation was riding that night;
And the spark struck out by that steed, in his flight,
Kindled the land into flame with its heat.
He has left the village and mounted the steep,
And beneath him, tranquil and broad and deep,
Is the Mystic, meeting the ocean tides;
And under the alders that skirt its edge,
Now soft on the sand, now loud on the ledge,
Is heard the tramp of his steed as he rides.

It was twelve by the village clock
When he crossed the bridge into Medford town.
He heard the crowing of the cock,
And the barking of the farmer's dog,
And felt the damp of the river fog,
That rises after the sun goes down.

It was one by the village clock,
When he galloped into Lexington.
He saw the gilded weathercock
Swim in the moonlight as he passed,
And the meeting-house windows, black and bare,
Gaze at him with a spectral glare,
As if they already stood aghast
At the bloody work they would look upon.

It was two by the village clock,
When he came to the bridge in Concord town.
He heard the bleating of the flock,
And the twitter of birds among the trees,
And felt the breath of the morning breeze
Blowing over the meadow brown.
And one was safe and asleep in his bed
Who at the bridge would be first to fall,
Who that day would be lying dead,
Pierced by a British musket ball.

You know the rest. In the books you have read
How the British Regulars fired and fled,---
How the farmers gave them ball for ball,
From behind each fence and farmyard wall,
Chasing the redcoats down the lane,
Then crossing the fields to emerge again
Under the trees at the turn of the road,
And only pausing to fire and load.

So through the night rode Paul Revere;
And so through the night went his cry of alarm
To every Middlesex village and farm,---
A cry of defiance, and not of fear,
A voice in the darkness, a knock at the door,
And a word that shall echo for evermore!
For, borne on the night-wind of the Past,
Through all our history, to the last,
In the hour of darkness and peril and need,
The people will waken and listen to hear
The hurrying hoof-beats of that steed,
And the midnight message of Paul Revere.

May these men never be forgotten. Without them, our nation never would have been.

NJ Budget - A Libertarian Point of View

I just ran across this post by Dr. Murray Sabrin, in which he presents the text of his testimony on the budget before the state Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee. He's got some interesting ideas about how to fix the state's budget problems.

On education funding:

• Amend the Constitution to abolish the “thorough and efficient” education clause, giving the Legislature control over school spending
• Amend the Constitution preventing the Supreme Court from ordering the Legislature or the executive branch to spend money for any purpose
About the only way to get the Supreme Court out of the school funding business is to explicitly invalidate Abbott and prevent it from coming back.
• Equalize state education aid. Every school district would get the same state aid per student as every other school district
This one I really like. The only truly fair way for the state to fund education is by linking the money to the students, rather than the schools or districts. Of course, it introduces other problems like inflation of attendance records.
• Implement education tax credits for individuals, families and businesses
Tie this to the previous item. Give the individual student or his parents gets a voucher that can be spent at any school in the state. [My, I'm starting to sound like a Libertarian, aren't I?]

On financial management:
• The state should implement forensic accountants Rosenfarb Winters recommendations regarding the Abbott Districts, which would save at least $282 million
Kinda cryptic reference, but I like the idea of saving 9-figure numbers.
• Institute zero based budgeting—all state agencies must justify every dollar it spends
We do this today, except the justification is usually "That's what we spent last year, you got a problem with that?"

On specific taxes:
• Reduce the sales tax by one cent every year for three years
Like it, but I'd go for six rather than three years.
• Reduce the personal income tax and the Corporate Business Tax
This is good, as long as we reduce the marginal rates to stimulate growth, rather than creating some phony scheme that eliminates taxpayers from the rolls. Unfortunately, the Governor has proposed option B.
• Eliminate the income tax on pensions
I don't know that this is such a good thing (see above re: eliminating taxpayers from the rolls)
• Raise the gas tax 20 cents per gallon only for road and bridge projects
More than doubling the gas tax (or any other tax) is a Bad Idea™.

On redistribution schemes:
• Eliminate property tax rebates, saving $1.5 billion per year
Great idea, as long as it's enacted along with the linkage of funds to students.
• Eliminate all state grants to nonprofits
Makes sense to me. I don't want my money funding West Jepepian Cultural Studies or other such nonsense. Many nonprofits do good work, but they all employ professional fundraisers and should not be reliant on state grants. Fee for service paid to nonprofits, however, would probably be a more efficient use of state tax dollars.
• End municipal grants
I don't think that I would completely eliminate them, but I would like to see tighter controls and elimination of favoritism toward committee chair pet projects. Transparency would be nice here.

On specific spending items:
• Begin the transition making the state colleges, Rutgers University, and the University of Medical and Dentistry of New Jersey financially independent
Considering the facts that Rutgers charges $237 per undergraduate credit hour in state ($484 out of state), has 28,000 students enrolled, and requires 120 credit-hours of course work to graduate, one would think they could generate a viable business model without state funding. By my back-of-the-envelope calculations, they take in somewhere around $200 million annually from tuition alone, assuming an 80/20 split between in-state and out and 4-5 years to graduate.
• Kill the Transportation Fund bond issue
All for this one, as well. The debt liabilities in the TTF need to be taken out of hide, like they should have been when they were incurred.

On fixing the business climate:
• End state government grants, loans, subsidies for businesses
• Abolish unnecessary business regulations
Absolutely. The state has no business in business. Set a low tax rate, keep it stable, get out of the way and watch things take off.

On general government reforms:
• Eliminate dual office holding
How the heck did we end up with this albatross, anyway?
• Eliminate pensions for part-time government employees
I spend at least an hour a year on paperwork for the benefit of the state, and in return I get a check. Is that enough to qualify me as a state employee for pension purposes?
• Eliminate pensions of legislators
I'm absolutely in favor of doing away with the permanent politician. Killing these pensions would remove a significant incentive for those in office to stay in office.

It's not surprising that Sabrin's ideas haven't gotten more attention, given that he was 51st on a list of 74 people testifying April 3rd, and has been a less-than-successful candidate for multiple statewide offices (Governor 97, Senate 00). I'll leave you with Sabrin's thoughts on the true source of our problem, with which I wholeheartedly agree.
The culture of entitlement and redistribution of income is so ingrained in the collective psyche of policymakers and many segments of the public, that few individuals can conceive of a society based on low taxes, less spending, less regulation, and limited government. Instead, too many of our citizens believe government’s prime responsibility is to be the social worker, the healthcare provider and the source of income for many of our families.
Policymakers must embrace economist Ludwig von Mises’s insight: “The government and its chiefs do not have the powers of the mythical Santa Claus. They cannot spend except by taking out of the pockets of some people for the benefit of others.”
Tags: New Jersey, Taxes, Budget

Friday, April 14, 2006

More on the New Jersey Budget

Enlighten New Jersey spends a little blog real estate to remind us that "There Are No Cuts In Governor Corzine's Budget."

Governor Jon Corzine and his supporters claim his proposed $30.9 state budget for 2007 is a fair and reasonable plan while acknowledging spending will climb 9.2% over last year’s budget of $28.3 billion. No matter how you try to spin it, Corzine’s budget will increase state spending by $2.6 billion.

Corzine has explained $1.63 billion of the increase with his proposed $1.1 billion payment to the state worker pension fund and his request for a $530 million increase in property tax rebates. So where is the remaining billion dollars in additional spending going? It’s being spent on the Governor’s priorities.
Conveniently, the Governor's Budget in Brief provides a detailed list of different budget line items that have either increased or decreased. Enlighten pointed out a few highlights, but some summary data would also be useful to emphasize the magnitude of the problem.

State Operations - $268,887,000 increase
  • 16 line items increased, totaling $690,608,000
  • 39 line items decreased, totaling $421,731,000
Two of the decreases, totalling $125 million, allegedly shift costs to the federal government. Given that New Jersey typically gets back 57 cents on every dollar sent to the feds, I am highly skeptical about the opportunity here.
Eighteen, for $108 million, come from "efficiencies" in each of the departments. There is no detail, as far as I can tell, about how the governor plans to make the bureaucracy more efficient. To gain efficiency in a business sense (our governor is a businessman, after all), we either have to produce more government services for the same cost, or produce the same government services for a lower cost. Enlighten points out that the state employs 154,700 people. 80,900 are full-time employees, which means that each full-time employee must produce an extra $1,340 worth of services to achieve $108 million in "efficiencies." At $40 / hour, that's 33.5 hours of extra work for each employee, or the equivalent of of 1,355 man-years of work. Think the unions will stand for that?
Four items worth $95 million aren't really spending decreases, because they reduce fund balances (Prescription Fund, Division of Pensions/Pension Fund, Governor's Contingency Funds, and Contingency Funds). This exactly the kind of budget trick the governor told us he wouldn't use.
Four line items, totalling $28 million, appear to be related to staffing reductions, including the governor's salary. It was so kind of him to sacrifice his $250,000 salary in the face of a $4,500,000,000 hole -- we're 0.0055% of the way there now!
Finally, there's a one-time savings similar to the campaign funding Enlighten pointed out -- we are "saving" $600,000 by not funding the Governor's transition as we did last year.

Grants-in-Aid - $885,514,000 increase
  • 36 items increased, totaling $1,708,960,000
  • 76 items decreased, totaling $823,446,000
The governor finds more creative ways to give away our money. I suppose I should be encouraged by the $250,000 reduction to Weehawken Arts. The largest Grants-in Aid "reduction" is $215,000,000 attributed to the Hospital Provider Assessment. This is really a half of a new, $430,000,000 tax (Budget in Brief, page 6). Calling it a cost reduction is nothing more than a big fat lie.

State Aid - $1,007,679,000 increase
  • 15 items increased, totaling $1,165,754,000
  • 19 items decreased, totaling $158,075,000
The big increase, $744,117,000 to the Teacher's Pension and Annuity Fund, dwarfs all of the savings combined. Even excluding this pension funding, the increases are still more than 2.5 times the decreases. This is a "hard choices" budget? Hardly.

The bottom line, again from Enlighten New Jersey's post:
So it goes throughout Corzine's budget – a small cut here and a large increase somewhere else in his budget plan In the end, Governor Corzine has funded his priorities and his priorities are costing the state’s taxpayers an additional $2.6 billion.

Tags: Jersey, Taxes, Budget

Tuesday, April 11, 2006

Smackdown

Chanice at New Jersey for Change really lays into Steven Pressman for his article calling for higher income taxes in New Jersey. She says to read the whole article, and you should, but here's his opening salvo to wet your whistle:

In 1993, when President Clinton took office, the U.S. economy faced an enormous budget deficit. His response was twofold. First, he increased income taxes on the wealthiest Americans. Second, he increased the tax on a gallon of gasoline. To help poorer families pay for the higher gas taxes, he increased the earned income tax credit — a tax break for low-income households where someone works.

The result of these actions was the longest economic expansion in U.S. history. Unemployment dropped to below 4 percent, a level rarely seen in this country. And perhaps most important of all, a massive government budget deficit became a huge budget surplus, which has since been squandered by President Bush.

I always love it when liberals engage in the fallacy of post hoc, ergo propter hoc. It's even more fun when they include no data to support their assertions. Here's what Pressman leaves out. According to data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, real economic growth was accelerating throughout 1993, from 0.12% in the 1st quarter to 1.35% in the 4th. In the 8 quarters leading up to implementation of Clinton's marginal rate increase, average real growth was 0.82% per quarter. In the 8 quarters following (Q1 1994 to Q4 1995), average real growth was 0.76%. The rate increase did not create "the longest economic expansion in U.S. history," it slowed an expansion already underway. Here are some handy charts to illustrate. The first shows real GDP growth from the BEA data linked above, while the second is the percentage of the population employed according to the Household Survey, from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.





As shown in the national data, increasing marginal income tax rates tends to suppress, not encourage, real economic growth. Pressman asserts that higher tax rates cause economic growth, which is demonstrably false. The rest of his argument for curing New Jersey's budget ills, based on this fallacy, doesn't hold water.

The only way out of this mess is to grow spending at a slower rate than we grow revenue. Until the governor proposes (and the legislature enacts) a plan that will constrain the spending side of the equation, we will never win.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes, Budget

Saturday, April 08, 2006

The New Jersey Budget Problem

In an article headlined New Jersey lawmakers unlikely to get last-minute budget reprieve, Tom Hester Jr. of the Associated Press writes:

Much like prisoners awaiting execution, state lawmakers in recent years have spent budget deliberations waiting for last minute reprieves in the form of unanticipated tax collections.
Last year, for instance, an unforeseen $1 billion increase in tax revenue helped legislators balance the budget without having to ax most property tax rebates or approve $150 million in proposed new taxes.
But lawmakers are realizing that the reality of New Jersey's fiscal mess, coupled with the state's sluggish economy, offer little hope for a late spring windfall.
That means that _ just as Gov. Jon S. Corzine has suggested _ they may have to actually cut programs and increases taxes as the July 1 deadline to approve an approximately $31 billion budget nears.
As usual, the NJ state legislature is hoping for some way to spend more of our tax dollars. In the article, Democrat Lou Greenwald, chairman of the Assembly Budget Committee, discusses his plan to reduce spending:
"What our goal will be is to find more waste and better efficiencies"

Pretty strong, isn't it? I can't wait to see how the Assembly finds more efficient ways to waste our money.
Assembly Republicans aren't much better.
Assemblyman Joseph Malone, R-Burlington, wants to eliminate a state grant program that this fiscal year provided $3,000 grants for activities such as duck decoy carving, basket making and Indian music lessons.
"It may not be a lot of money, but it's symptomatic of the disregard that some people in state government have for the financial problems we have in the state of New Jersey," Malone said. "It's just incomprehensible."

I suppose it's progress to see an actual proposed cut, but couldn't they be a little more aggressive about it? I'd like to see some true reform, with a bold vision for change rather than sniping around the edges.
For example, they could cap state spending on education at some percentage of Gross State Product. Any excess funds collected through the income tax could be returned to the taxpayers through annual "rebates" or even - perish the thought - rate reductions. Even if they set it at today's level, if they would distribute the funds equitably amongst the school districts we would generate huge benefits for most New Jersey property tax payers.
Unfortunately, our New Jersey Republican Party doesn't have the intestinal fortitude to create, much less hold on to, any kind of vision.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes, Budget, Pork

Sunday, April 02, 2006

Illegal Aliens

Jim at Parkway Rest Stop tells the story of Hector, inspired by the things he's been reading in the news. Amazing how a little dialogue can clarify an issue.
My take on this is simple: in general, immigration is a good thing. We need to continually refill the melting pot of America with new materials, or we won't be able to sustain our growth and prosperity. It must, however, be done within the law, and towards the end of becoming American. Those who go outisde the system are violating our laws, and should not be rewarded for that violation. They have no "right" to the benefits earned by those with the determination to become citizens.

Sunday, March 26, 2006

NJ Budget - Expanding Health Insurance for Children II

In our last installment, I noted that

Family Care has added 278,928 kids and 141,516 adults due to the enactment of the "Family Health Care Coverage Act," boosting its penetration to 25% of the total market for children's health insurance.
The Governor's budget proposes spending $5,000,000 to recruit 50,000 more children into the program. That's $100 for each and every child added.

Enlighten New Jersey and Paul Nelson of NJ Fiscal Folly have uncovered some additional facts showing that this increase will do nothing for our fiscal problems. First, in the comments on my first post, Enlighten notes a line from the Budget in Brief:
"$70 million – Medicaid and a FamilyCare shortfall caused by higher than anticipated enrollments, increased drug costs, and a shift to the General Fund of costs that are no longer supported by the Health Care Subsidy Fund."
Based on this data, we could conclude that the additional 280,000 kids cost the state at least $250 each. Spending $5,000,000 to recruit 50,000 more would thus cost the state an additional $12,500,000. for a total expenditure of $17,500,000. This is not exactly a wise choice in the eyes of the typical investment banker, but there may be more to it than that.

Fortunately, Paul Nelson found that there is more to it. He researched the legislation that caused the drastic increase in FY06 costs, and found this [emphasis mine]:
The Office of Legislative Services (OLS), which provides professional, nonpartisan staff support services to the NJ Legislature, analyzed various costs related to the NJ FamilyCare program (go to page 6 of this June 2005 Senate Budget Committee report). The OLS found that the state spends $113 per month for each child in the program. For every additional 10,000 children, the gross annual cost (paid with both state and Federal funds) would be $13.6 million. Thus, the cost of an additional 50,000 children would be $68 million per year, not $14.3 million as Corzine claims in his proposed budget.
One thing that Paul missed, is that the $14,300,000 increase is not all intended to pay for the recurring cost. As I noted above, $5,000,000 of that total is intended to support growing a losing business, and the governor has irresponsibly planned an additional $9,300,000 for an additional expense which he surely knows will be significantly larger.

Given that this expenditure cannot possibly be motivated by fiscal reasons, I can only conclude that it is being made for political ones. The far left has long been enamored with the failing single-payer health care system of Canada and other quasi-socialist states. They attempted to enact one nationwide early in the Clinton administration. I believe Governor Corzine's goal is to create such a system here in New Jersey. Why else would he be spending the taxpayers' money in an attempt to corner the health insurance market for children? He's already got 24% of the 18-and-under crowd locked in, and wants to expand his "customer" base by 10% this year.

Governor Corzine, the state is losing money on each and every person added. Children are not a loss-leader, and you can't make it up on volume. Drop your plan to take over state-wide health insurance.

Tags: New Jersey, Budget, Corzine, Health Care, Children

Thursday, March 23, 2006

NJ Budget - Expanding Health Insurance for Children

In his campaign health care plan, Jon Corzine claimed he would expand health insurance availability to 265,000 uninsured children. Back in June 2005, I questioned that plan. The latest data available at the time (from June 2004) showed 229,743 people enrolled in the plan.

A few census facts are in order here. There are estimated to be 8,414,350 people living in New Jersey, of whom 24% (2,087,558) are aged 18 and under. There are 669,668 individuals below the poverty level, or 8.3% of the population.

If the proportion of children among those in poverty is the same as that of the general population, then there are about 161,000 children in poverty. This ties pretty closely with the census estimate of 135,549 families below the poverty level.

The latest Family Care data, from Feb 2006, indicate that 508,671 children and 141,516 adults are now enrolled. Family Care has added 278,928 kids and 141,516 adults due to the enactment of the "Family Health Care Coverage Act," boosting its penetration to 25% of the total market for children's health insurance.

Why should we spend $5 million of additional state funds? Give the existing legislation, only in effect for the past six months, time to work. We do not need "aggressive interdepartmental collaborative efforts to maximize existing enrollment opportunities," nor do we need "targeted marketing and outreach" to recruit an additional 50,000 children, especially when those children are likely to come from the upper end of the allowed 350% of the poverty level. Our state plan currently provides insurance for more than 3 times the estimated number of children living in poverty.

Leave well enough alone, Governor Corzine. Government should not be a growth industry.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes, Health Care, Corzine, Budget

Wednesday, March 22, 2006

New Jersey 2007 State Budget - First Impressions

I've just finished reading Governor Corzine's Budget in Brief. I'm putting together some thoughts on specific issues, but wanted to point out something I think is missing.

How many people does the state employ? How many people are currently eligible for state-funded pensions? What has been the change in those numbers over the last several years?

I cannot find these basic facts anywhere in the Budget. Since "mandatory" increases in wages and benefits are driving a large percentage of the higher spending each year, I think it's important for the taxpayers to be provided with this information. The governor tells us in the highlights:

Reduction of more than 1,000 staff positions with accompanying savings of $54 million through a rigorous hiring freeze, administrative efficiencies and responsible reorganization of select government functions. Limiting the filling of attrited vacancies will yield opportunities to not only control government growth but also to do more with less by enhancing management efficiencies and streamlining services
What he's not telling us is how much of an impact this "reduction" will have on the overall budget. I find it hard to believe that the average government employee only costs the state $54,000 per year.

I will follow with more questions later. In the meantime, stop in to see Enlighten New Jersey, Dynamobuzz, NJ Fiscal Folly, and NJ Conservative for more interesting commentary.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes, Spending, Corzine

Monday, March 20, 2006

A Conversation with a Seven-Year-Old Cub Scout

While in the car this evening after a den meeting, my second grade Cub Scout noticed that the outside temperature was 40 degrees Fahrenheit. A few minutes into the ride to pick up his older sister at the dance studio, he remarked as the temperature was falling, first to 39 then 38 degrees.
I asked him if such rapid temperature change in a short time meant that it would keep dropping until it got below zero tonight. "Dad, don't be silly," he responded. "The temperature can't keep changing like that!"
A few minutes later, the temperature jumped back up to 39 degrees. So I asked him, "Does this mean the temperature will keep rising now?"
"No way!" he shouted from the back seat.

Why is it that a seven-year-old understands that short term trends cannot be extrapolated to predict long term behavior of a particular measurement, but "most scientists" as portrayed by the media ignore this?

Tags: Kids, Global Warming

Carnival Time

The Carnival of the New Jersey Bloggers is up over at The Center of New Jersey Life. Sharon does her usual fine job of hosting.

Also, one of my posts was included in the Carnival of the GOP Bloggers! I mentioned this new carnival a few weeks ago. Go check it out.

Tags: Carnival of the New Jersey Bloggers, Carnival of the GOP Bloggers

Saturday, March 18, 2006

Definition Time

I normally don't do this, but I've seen so much in the press and on the NJ blogosphere lately that I just have to point this out. Forgive me for shouting, but I feel it's necessary in this case.

REDUCING THE SIZE OF A SPENDING INCREASE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A SPENDING CUT. IT IS STILL A SPENDING INCREASE.

That is all.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes

Friday, March 17, 2006

A Conservative Goes to the Library

[Welcome, Carnival of the New Jersey Bloggers and Carnival of the GOP Bloggers! Thanks for stopping by.]

Thurman Hart, the Xpatriated Texan at BlueJersey.net, writes: Ken is a liar. He's trying to fool us all! Don't let him snow you. Or words to that effect. What he really says is that my post on the State Business Tax Climate Index is "intentionally misleading" and contains "disturbingly inaccurate info."
Let me start by stating that Thurman appears to care about the subjects on which he writes, and is normally polite in his discourse, so when I saw that he had linked to my post, I was encouraged that someone from the left side of the blogosphere wanted to engage in debate on the subject. My encouragement quickly turned to disappointment when I read his introductory remarks. As a former naval officer and Naval Academy graduate, I have always tried to conduct myself honorably. To be called a liar in a public forum is a slap in the face, and is very much unappreciated. While Thurman may disagree with my conclusions about the data, none of the information provided is inaccurate (although I did make one mathematical error, as described below). It is all verifiable at the links I provided to the State Business Tax Climate Index and the Gross State Product Report. (For the true geek, the actual data behind the report on GSP is here.)
Thurman appears to have gone to the data, and includes in his post the growth rates and growth ranks for each state I listed in the top and bottom 10. What I said was that "overall US growth rate was 4.3 percent," "the top 10 states ... hit an average of 4.67 percent," and "the bottom 10 states averaged 3.44 percent." He attempts to refute my analysis by pointing out that two of the top 10 business tax climate states, "Wyoming and Alaska badly underperform," and 60% of the states in the top 10 meet or exceed the national average. In Thurman's view, 60% beating the average isn't good enough. Unfortunately, his view is based on a flawed analysis - only the two states he cites, Wyoming and Alaska, are below the 4.3% national average, while Montana equals it, as shown in this copy of his table (emphasis added).

StateTax Climate RankGrowth RateGrowth Rank
Wyoming13.340
S. Dakota24.520
Alaska33.438
Florida45.95
Nevada59.31
New Hampshire65.49
Texas74.617
Delaware85.012
Montana94.325
Oregon104.519

He then really confuses matters by trying to average the rankings and compare it to the median ranking, and excluding the highest percentage performer, Nevada, from the comparison to reinforce his position that the difference isn't really all that significant. Problem is, it's apparent that he averaged the growth rates, without accounting for the total growth in each of the states involved. He states that "If you separate Nevada from the rest, the average drops to 4.5." His calculation is correct for his flawed methodology, but doesn't really tell you the complete story. To do that, you have to sum the total GSPs and total growth, not average the averages.


Dollars in millions


State 2004 Total Percent Growth 03-04 03 Total 03-04 Growth Overall Tax Climate Rank
Wyoming 23,979 3.3 23,213 766 1
South Dakota 29,386 4.5 28,121 1,265 2
Alaska 34,023 3.4 32,904 1,119 3
Florida 599,068 5.9 565,692 33,376 4
Nevada 100,317 9.3 91,781 8,536 5
New Hampshire 51,871 5.4 49,213 2,658 6
Texas 884,136 4.6 845,254 38,882 7
Delaware 54,274 5.0 51,690 2,584 8
Montana 27,482 4.3 26,349 1,133 9
Oregon 128,103 4.5 122,587 5,516 10
Top 10 States 1,932,639 5.2% 1,836,804 95,835
Percentage of US 16.6%
16.4% 19.9%


With Nevada in the mix, the combined growth rate for the top 10 states is 5.2%.[1] Without Nevada, the combined growth rate falls to 5.0%. Thurman's argument doesn't hold water here. His method is akin to computing a team batting average by totalling the averages of each player, then dividing by the number of players. These states taken in the aggregate significantly outperform the nation as a whole, even if you exclude the top performer.
The next attempt to portray my analysis as "intentionally misleading" and inaccurate looked at the bottom 10 states. Thurman points out, correctly, that 40% "outperform" the US economy. His conclusion "guess," that "it must be something besides tax rates" is obviously correct, but not pursued or supported by any other data or analysis. What exactly is it then, Thurman? 70% of states with favorable business tax climates outperformed the US economy, while 60% of states with unfavorable business tax climates underperformed. I stand by my conclusion.
Let's put it another way. Look at the economic performance of the bottom 10 states, and compare with the top 10.


Dollars in millions


State 2004 Total Percent Growth 03-04 03 Total 03-04 Growth Overall Tax Climate Rank
Arkansas 80,902 5.3 76,830 4,072 41
Iowa 111,114 5.5 105,321 5,793 42
Nebraska 68,183 1.5 67,175 1,008 43
Kentucky 136,446 3.7 131,578 4,868 44
Maine 43,336 3.9 41,709 1,627 45
Vermont 21,921 4.6 20,957 964 46
Ohio 419,866 2.6 409,226 10,640 47
Rhode Island 41,679 3.5 40,270 1,409 48
New Jersey 416,053 3.4 402,372 13,681 49
New York 896,739 4.7 856,484 40,255 50
Bottom 10 States 2,236,239 3.9% 2,151,923 84,316
Percentage of US 19.2%
19.2% 17.5%


The monetary difference in growth between the top 10 and bottom 10 states is large.


2003 Economy 03-04 Growth
Top 10 $ 1,836,804 $ 95,835
Bottom 10 $ 2,151,923 $ 84,316
Delta $ (315,119) $ 11,519
% Delta -14.6% 13.7%


The top 10 states generated $95.8 billion in growth, while the bottom 10 states generated $84.3 billion in growth starting from a much larger base. Their favorable tax climate let them create 13.7% more economic growth, using 14.6% less working capital. If these were companies, in which one would you invest? The data clearly show that states with a favorable business tax climate, in general, outperform the states with unfavorable business tax climates.

Tags: New Jersey, Taxes

p.s. Thanks to Enlighten-New Jersey and New Jersey for Change for weighing in on this as well.

________________
[1] As I put together this rebuttal, I realized that I had made a calculation error. The top 10 states did not average 4.67% growth as I had noted. As you can see from the table, the average growth was actually 5.2%. I can't account for the error (didn't save my working Excel™ file), and I stand corrected on this point. This correction will also be appended to the original.

Monday, March 13, 2006

Budget Priorities

Enlighten-NewJersey says, "Tell Corzine No Tax Increases - Cut Spending."

The Courier Post recently conducted a survey on how Gov. Jon Corzine should balance the state budget. The number one choice was “cut government jobs and benefits”, favored by two thirds of the voters. The second highest vote getter was “cut services”.
The choice Governor Corzine seems to be leaning toward, “increase taxes and spending”, is not an option favored by the people of New Jersey, at least not taxpayers reading the Courier Post.


I agree with Enlighten (surprise!), and decided to send the governor a little note about the subject. Here's what I wrote, via his email web form:
Dear Governor Corzine,

With regard to the Fiscal Year 2007 budget as briefed in your recent town hall meetings, I believe you have your priorities exactly backwards. The slides presented talked about how dire the spending problem is, yet did not offer a coherent plan to reduce spending. In fact, it appears that your budget plan increases spending by over 17% from the current fiscal year.
I find this level of increase to be totally unacceptable. I demand that you reduce spending significantly. From 1997-2004, state expenditures (from your presentation) grew at an annual rate of approximately 7.3%, while Gross State Product grew at an annual rate of 5.5% (unadjusted for inflation). Had we held state spending growth to the rate of economic growth, our 2004 expenditures would have been $22.4 billion rather than $24.5 billion, and we would have spent $12.6 billion less over the cumulative seven year period.
Your plan, as presented, states that expenses "will grow" at an annual rate of over 10.5% from 2007-2010, despite projected revenue growth of only 3-4% annually.
It would be appropriate, in my opinion, to set a baseline for your budget based on the growth in the economy over the long term (say, 10 years or so), so that the sustainable level of revenue based on current taxes covers spending. If the sustainable revenue does not support a new program, then that program must not be initiated. It would be much more fair to the taxpayers, and more favorable to the business climate, to have a stable tax code over a long period, rather than having the constant threat of new taxes deterring financial decisions.
There are reports that the state has collected some $500 million in excess of this year's budgeted revenue, due to the strength of economic growth this year. Those funds must not be spent frivolously, but should be used to either reduce next year's tax burden, or to satisfy some of the unfunded liabilities you highlighted in your briefing. It would be irresponsible to take this excess revenue as "found money" and expend it to the for other purposes.
Governor Corzine, it is vitally important to the future of our state that you get our spending house in order. The state collects more money than it budgets, yet every year reports a "budget hole" in the billions of dollars. Break the cycle and restore fiscal sanity to our government by stopping the spending increases.

Tags: New Jersey, Spending, Taxes, Corzine